lunes, 23 de junio de 2008

What do you think about this experience?


Won’t You Be My Neighbor? Published: June 23, 2008 in The New York Times.
Brighton, N.Y.

THE alarm on my cellphone rang at 5:50 a.m., and I awoke to find myself in a twin bed in a spare room at my neighbor Lou’s house.
Lou was 81. His six children were grown and scattered around the country, and he lived alone, two doors down from me. His wife, Edie, had died five years earlier. “When people learn you’ve lost your wife,” he told me, “they all ask the same question. ‘How long were you married?’ And when you tell them 52 years, they say, ‘Isn’t that wonderful!’ But I tell them no, it isn’t. I was just getting to know her.”
Lou had said he gets up at six, but after 10 more minutes, I heard nothing from his room down the hall. Had he died? He had a heart ailment, but generally was in good health. With a full head of silver-gray hair, bright hazel-blue eyes and a broad chest, he walked with the confident bearing of a man who had enjoyed a long and satisfying career as a surgeon.
The previous evening, as I’d left home, the last words I heard before I shut the door had been, “Dad, you’re crazy!” from my teenage daughter. Sure, the sight of your 50-year-old father leaving with an overnight bag to sleep at a neighbor’s house would embarrass any teenager, but “crazy”? I didn’t think so.
There’s talk today about how as a society we’ve become fragmented by ethnicity, income, city versus suburb, red state versus blue. But we also divide ourselves with invisible dotted lines. I’m talking about the property lines that isolate us from the people we are physically closest to: our neighbors.
It was a calamity on my street, in a middle-class suburb of Rochester, several years ago that got me thinking about this. One night, a neighbor shot and killed his wife and then himself; their two middle-school-age children ran screaming into the night. Though the couple had lived on our street for seven years, my wife and I hardly knew them. We’d see them jogging together. Sometimes our children would carpool.
Some of the neighbors attended the funerals and called on relatives. Someone laid a single bunch of yellow flowers at the family’s front door, but nothing else was done to mark the loss. Within weeks, the children had moved with their grandparents to another part of town. The only indication that anything had changed was the “For Sale” sign on the lawn.
A family had vanished, yet the impact on our neighborhood was slight. How could that be? Did I live in a community or just in a house on a street surrounded by people whose lives were entirely separate? Few of my neighbors, I later learned, knew others on the street more than casually; many didn’t know even the names of those a few doors down.
According to social scientists, from 1974 to 1998, the frequency with which Americans spent a social evening with neighbors fell by about one-third. Robert Putnam, the author of “Bowling Alone,” a groundbreaking study of the disintegration of the American social fabric, suggests that the decline actually began 20 years earlier, so that neighborhood ties today are less than half as strong as they were in the 1950s.
Why is it that in an age of cheap long-distance rates, discount airlines and the Internet, when we can create community anywhere, we often don’t know the people who live next door?
Maybe my neighbors didn’t mind living this way, but I did. I wanted to get to know the people whose houses I passed each day — not just what they do for a living and how many children they have, but the depth of their experience and what kind of people they are.
What would it take, I wondered, to penetrate the barriers between us? I thought about childhood sleepovers and the insight I used to get from waking up inside a friend’s home. Would my neighbors let me sleep over and write about their lives from inside their own houses?
A little more than a year after the murder-suicide, I began to telephone my neighbors and send e-mail messages; in some cases, I just walked up to the door and rang the bell. The first one turned me down, but then I called Lou. “You can write about me, but it will be boring,” he warned. “I have nothing going on in my life — nothing. My life is zero. I don’t do anything.”
Peter Lovenheim, the author of “Portrait of a Burger as a Young Calf,” is writing a book about neighborhoods.
That turned out not to be true. When Lou finally awoke that morning at 6:18, he and I shared breakfast. Then he lay on a couch in his study and, skipping his morning nap, told me about his grandparents’ immigration, his Catholic upbringing, his admission to medical school despite anti-Italian quotas, and how he met and courted his wife, built a career and raised a family.
Later, we went to the Y.M.C.A. for his regular workout; he mostly just kibitzed with friends. We ate lunch. He took a nap. We watched the business news. That evening, he made us dinner and talked of friends he’d lost, his concerns for his children’s futures and his own mortality.
Before I left, Lou told me how to get into his house in case of an emergency, and I told him where I hide my spare key. That evening, as I carried my bag home, I felt that in my neighbor’s house lived a person I actually knew.
I was privileged to be his friend until he died, just this past spring.
Remarkably, of the 18 or so neighbors I eventually approached about sleeping over, more than half said yes. There was the recently married young couple, both working in business; the real estate agent and her two small children; the pathologist married to a pediatrician who specializes in autism.
Eventually, I met a woman living three doors away, the opposite direction from Lou, who was seriously ill with breast cancer and in need of help. My goal shifted: could we build a supportive community around her — in effect, patch together a real neighborhood? Lou and I and some of the other neighbors ended up taking turns driving her to doctors’ appointments and watching her children.
Our political leaders speak of crossing party lines to achieve greater unity. Maybe we should all cross the invisible lines between our homes and achieve greater unity in the places we live. Probably we don’t need to sleep over; all it might take is to make a phone call, send a note, or ring a bell. Why not try it today?

Peter Lovenheim, the author of “Portrait of a Burger as a Young Calf,” is writing a book about neighborhoods.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/23/opinion/23lovenheim.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&th&emc=th

38 comentarios:

Anónimo dijo...

I really enjoyed the way in which the author of this article shows the theme and gives us a message. I agree with him entirely because since my experience, having a good relationship with our neighbours makes us feel happy, relieved and, in some way, accompanied by them.
Personally, my family and I have an excellent relationship with our neighbours. We share chats every weeks and I am sure that if I have a problem, they will not be doubtful about helping me. I always remember the day in which an old man, who lived next door to me, died. As he was lonely and he had no money, the neighbours of my block sympathized with him and they gave him a wake before his funeral. It was not the best way they found to join together but it was necessary and they did not doubt that they had to do it.
However, I believe that my experience is a special one since as the author expresses, today neighborhood ties are not strong as they were some years ago when neighbours shared parties, chats, problems, goods and everything you can imagine. Nowadays, all those things have been lost.
People should really value their neighbours since if they need something, their neighbours are the closest to them,and the other way round. If you need sugar...who are the closest to you??Yes!!your neighbour!!!

Anónimo dijo...

I would say that nowadays, we live in a world in which everyone is busy and always in a rush. Many times, we only pay attention to our job, profession or even our problems and not to the people we love (family, friends and neighbours). I include in my list my neighbours since I have a good relationship with them, of course that not with all of them but at least I have three families with which we spend some time chatting.

The other day I realised that I have a new neighbour who is more or less five houses from my house. I saw the girl once and then, when I went to Dopazo School last Thursday I came to know that one of the students in the course where I observed some classes is my neighbour. Thus, I asked her how long she has been living there and the answer was a year! I couldn’t believe that.

Well, the point is that today, we have many means of communication but in fact, we forget to really communicate with each other.

Unknown dijo...

I believe that nowadays people who belong to the same neighbourhood don´t join together or even don´t know each other either, especially because of individualism.Some people pay attention to their lives and are only concerned about what happens to them and their relatives. It is really noticeable the need for constructive dialogue owing to the everyday conflicts which arise among people. Besides, all people have to take advantage from the new technologies so as to know the necessities each of them has and try to get agreements to ensure the community harmony.

RobertaZimm dijo...

I think that the way we relate in my neighborhood have changed mainly because we, neighbors, have grown up, become adults and adapted to the new times. However, I keep very dear memories of them during my childhood. There were the ones who told me when to cross the street when I was too young to do it on my own, and there were the ones who told me off when I rang their bell and run away. The three best friends I had as a child are my three next-door neighbors and the whole block was the place to spend the never ending summer afternoons. So, times are changing, yes, but my neighbors’ children are still playing on the pavement. Maybe they play with an electronic game instead of a rope, but I think the essence of getting together to have a good time is still in the air. At least, our younger ones have noticed that fact.

RobertaZimm dijo...

Again, I forgot to mention that the previous was written by Meli L.

Unknown dijo...

Well, I don’t usually see most of my neighbours either because they are doing different things outside home, working or studying. So, I don’t really get involved with my neigbours pretty much. That’s why we don’t get to know each other. Besides, nowadays, everybody is rushing around and sometimes, it’s impossible to cope with the pace of life.

I haven’t really had problems with my neighbours except that, as I live in an apartment, when my neighbours make too much noise, it’s really hard to concentrate if I am studying. Similarly, when someone is listening to loud music, I’m sure all people from the contiguous apartments can hear that too.

To tell you the truth, most of the times, I prefer keeping myself to myself. However, I always try to be friendly towards my neighbours any time I meet them. Perhaps we don’t go to everybody’s houses or talk to much but we know that we are always there if anyone needs help.

Ikelarile dijo...

Regrettably, I don’t have many neighbours. In fact, I can’t count more than two; a mad old man across the street and a couple with a baby who are never at home since both of them are doctors…Well, I only run into them once in a blue moon, and when that happens we just look at each other like saying “I’ve seen you somewhere before” but, that’s it. I wish I had neighbours to chat with, or to exchange a predictable “Merry Christmas and happy new year!” at least once in 365 days. I believe Peter Lovenheim successfully reflects through his story the fact that, although we have access to a developing communication industry, we hardly ever establish bonds with those who live next-door; which in the end, is kind of a paradox…isn’t it?

Sofía dijo...

I really like the story for it reflects what is happening in our society nowadays. That is the reason why I agree with the writer.
It is a fact that people do not usually talk to their neighbours or spend some hours with them speaking about experiences and life. Generally, people do not know anything about someone who lives next door. It seems that they do not care living this way for they usually consider someone who asks about others’ private lives an intolerable gossip. What is more, there are some people who do not even say hello to their neighbours when they meet them anywhere.
From my point of view, these things happen because we are living in an individualistic society where other persons’ problems or feelings are not taken into account. Besides, as we are split into different groups according to income, race, ideas, etc., it is difficult for us to live as a supportive community where people help each other and share memories and experiences.
Although it is difficult, we should try to cross the social barriers that do not let us live as a united and sympathetic neighbourhood.

Unknown dijo...
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
Unknown dijo...

I remember that when I was a child I used to spend hours in my neighbours' houses and my parents were friend of most of them. We always helped each other and got together to celebrate Christmas and new year. It was really great!
Unfortunatelly, some years ago everything changed. Some people died, others sold their houses, and newcomers moved to the neighbourhood. These new neighbours belong to different provinces and they aren't very greagrious so we don't know them very much. It's a pity because living in a close-knit neghbourhood makes you feel more secure and accompanied. Moreover, you know you can count on your neighbours to help you at any time.
Meli M.

Unknown dijo...

I must say the author has a point (although I would not go and sleep over in my neighbours'). His idea and most of all his intentions are good and rarely found in any of us. I think I’d have never thought of something similar because I don’t care much about my neighbours. Personally, I have always preferred my own company, maybe because I was way too shy to make friends. Besides, as my parents aren’t so social, the fact of not making friends with the neighbours has run in the family.
Honestly, I believe neighbours may be of a great help in many circumstances, so in spite of not being so close my family and I have a good relationship with them.

Unknown dijo...

Let me say that I have always had the same neighbours on the right and on the left since I was born! ON the right I have a couple of old people who don´t have any children, and have an excellente relationship with us! We hit it off. But, on the left, We have a very complaining neightbours who,last year sent us the police because my dog was barking at 3.00 pm and they could´t sleep the siesta! Of course, we have never said anything about it, because as Florencia said, If you need something, the closest to you are your neightbours... so, it is much better to ignore them and keep on living as if anything wouldn´t happen.

Liliana dijo...

To Florencia: It's good to hear you and your family have a very good relatinship with your neighbours. I agree with you on the fact that it's not only nice but also necessary to communicate well with the people who live near you.
Now, I would like you to read Paola's comment and post the corrections you would make to it (peer editing!). Thanks.
By the way, what's your neighbourhood in Rafaela?

Liliana dijo...

To Paola: yes! Isn't it so sad that having such sophisticated and developed ways of communication we are more isolated than ever in some cases? However, to realize that is happening to us is the first step to make things right again! So, congratulations on your decision to acknowledge your new neighbour!
You have a new task to fulfill now: read Florencia's comment and post the corrections you can make to it (peer editing). She'll do the same with yours. Thanks!!!

Liliana dijo...

To Virgi: "individualism" and "dialogue"... two words in your comment that I believe hold the key to the cause and the solution to the problem of communication among human beings nowadays. I couldn't agree more! It seems it all comes down to a question of becoming aware and doing something about it.
Virgi, your next task is to read Meli La's comment and post the improvements you would make to it. She will do the same with your writing. Thanks!
By the way, do people communicate more in your town than in Rafaela?

Liliana dijo...

To Meli (La): What nice memories of my childhood came up to my mind when I read your comment!!! Thanks! I had so much pleasure remembering "el tabletero" (ah! I bet you don't know what it is!!) passing by during siesta time selling ice cream in the shape of "tabletas".
Yes! Our neighbourhood is important in our life, mainly as the place where we grew up and made our first friends probably.
Meli, your next task is to read Virginia's commment and post the corrections or improvements you would make to it. Thanks.

Liliana dijo...

To Nati: yes, it's true it's hard to keep up with everything and it seems we have no time left to share with our neighbours. I also believe communication with people who live near you depends, to some extend, on the type of place you live in. It may be that if in your neighbouhood most families are young and most mothers work, there's little time left for chatting. In those places where there are a lot of retired people, the situation is different. Anyway, it's nice to know that as you go along in life, you get the chance to experience different things, even with your neighbours!
Nati, your next task is to read Maria's comment and post any correction, suggestion or improvements you would make to her piece. She will do the same with your writing. Thanks!

Liliana dijo...

To Maria: Sorry to hear you have few neighbours and little communication with them. What neighbourhood do you live in? Have you always lived there? Well... you never know what may happen in the future. You may find yourself sorrounded by warm and talkative people... who knows! This might be a point to keep in mind if later on in your life you have to move and choose a place to bring up kids. I suggest you read Melina Lasorella's comment. It seems neighbourhoods are very important places in our childhood.
Yes, many aspects of our culture are paradoxical, communication being one of them.
Maria, your next task is to read Natalia's comment and post any corrections or suggestions you can make to improve her writing. She will do the same with yours. Thanks!

Liliana dijo...

To Sofia: Very nice thoughts Sofi!! I agree with you completely! It would be nice if we all made the effort to build a community characterized by solidarity and empathy, leaving aside our individualism. Well, it only takes one person to start and many more will join, I'm sure!
Your next task is to read Meli M's comment and post any corrections or suggestion you would make to it to improve it. She will do the same with your writing. Thanks!

Liliana dijo...

To Meli M: Well, even if now communication with your neighbours has changed, at least you have had nice experiences in your childhood which give you the idea of how important bonds among human beings are. You may even try to do something about it, like taking the first step to become acquainted with some of your new neighbours. It might be worth it!
Meli, your next task is to read Gise's comment and post any corrections or suggestions you would make to her writing to improve it. She will do the same with yours. Thanks!

Liliana dijo...

To Gise: that's exactly why I posted the NY Times article. I thought the writer's idea was almost unique and a contribution to a world in which communication has developed greatly but we have little connection with poeple who sorround us.
Gise, your next task is to read Meli M's comment and post any corrections or suggestions you would make to it to improve it. She will do the same with yours. Thanks!

Liliana dijo...

To Melina Marengo and Sofia: sorry girl! I made a mistake. You have to check each other's work.

Liliana dijo...

To Gisela: sorry! I made a mistake in my previous comment. You have to post suggestions on JULIETA's work and she'll do it on yours.

Liliana dijo...

To Julieta: I agree with you on the point that relationships aren't always easy! But we have to make an effort to get along with our neighbours. I've been through a few similar negative experiences in life but I have also had great people next door with whom I've become friends for life. So... let's concentrate on the positive side of the question and go on doing our best, shall we?
Julieta, your next task is to read Gisela's comment and post any corrections or suggestions that you believe will improve her writing. She will do the same with yours. Thanks!

Unknown dijo...

Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
Well, this text really makes me think about the relationship I have with my neighbors. Fortunately, and proudly, I can say that I do know my neighbors, or at least some of them, those who live next doors. However, I realize that my relationship with them is not as close as that my grandparents had with theirs.
Bring to mind my childhood, I can see my grandmother gossiping with her neighbors, changing recipes or showing off their knitting. I can also picture my grandfather helping his neighbors with some minor repairs. Although my grandparents are still living in their old houses, some of their neighbors are not, some are in asylums, some have moved away and some have simply passed away.
Do they not have new neighbors? Of course, but they are young people always running taken care of their children, living their own lives. My grandparents just sit behind the window looking at the children playing.

Ikelarile dijo...

Peer work: Nati's writing

Well, I don’t usually see most of my neighbours either because they are doing different things outside home, most of the times working or because they’re studying. So, I don’t really get involved with my neighbours pretty much. That’s why we don’t get to know each other. Besides, nowadays, everybody is rushing around and sometimes, it’s impossible to cope with the pace of life.

I haven’t really had problems with my neighbours except that, as I live in an apartment, when (my neighbours) they make too much noise, it’s really hard for me to concentrate (if I am) / when studying. Similarly, when someone is listening to loud music, I’m sure all people from the contiguous apartments can hear (that too) / it.

To tell you the truth, most of the times, I prefer keeping myself to myself. However, I always try to be friendly towards my neighbours any time I (meet) / run into them. Perhaps we don’t go to everybody’s houses or talk too much but we know that we are always there if anyone needs help.


Nati: question: is there any particular neighbour you'd always be glad to help in case he’s in need? (e.g. if he forgets his keys je je)muaks ^_^

antonela dijo...

Finally! Sorry...

antonela dijo...

Sunday morning. I can hear the church bells ringing in the distance. The chilly days of winter make people enjoy sleeping until late when it is freezing outside. But, what is that distant murmuring? I cannot go back to sleep and I unwillingly get up, quite upset.
Once in the kitchen, I put the kettle on and draw back the curtains just to see some 80-year-old people gathered together in my front garden, near my bedroom window. “Excuse me,” I say, in a quite impolite tone, “can you, please, tell me what is going on here?”
“We are catching up, my dear. Sunday is the only day when we can meet,” answers a group of retired people who spend their time doing nothing but raking up the dead leaves or sharing rumours about other retired people from the neighbourhood.
It does not matter what I do, they always come back to my bedroom window to share a piece of their miserable lives. They do not care if it is Sunday, if it is 8 o’clock in the morning or if I have just arrived home from a tiring night at the disco. They will always wake me up.
That is why, when I read that “we have to cross the invisible lines between our homes and achieve greater unity in the places we live,” I laugh at that and think “who would want to know these people when you have already heard about their deadly boring lives Sunday after Sunday?”

RobertaZimm dijo...

I believe (that) nowadays people who belong to the same neighbourhood don´t join together or don´t even know each other/and don’t know each other either, especially because of individualism. Some people pay attention to their lives and are only concerned about what happens to them and to their relatives. It is really noticeable the need for constructive dialogue owing to (the) everyday conflicts which arise among people. Besides, (all) people have to take advantage from the new technologies so as to know the necessities each of them has/others have and try to get agreements to ensure (the) community harmony.

Meli(La)

Anónimo dijo...
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
Anónimo dijo...

Peer editing: Flo's work:

I really enjoyed the way in which the author of this article shows (develops) the theme (topic) and gives us a message. I (entirely) agree with him entirely because since (In my experience or from personal experience) my experience, having a good relationship with our neighbours makes us feel happy, relieved and, in some way, accompanied by them.
Personally, my family and I have an excellent relationship with our neighbours. We share chats every weeks and I am sure that if I have a problem, they will not be doubtful about helping me. I always remember the day in which (on which) an old man, who lived next door to me (not necessary), died. As he was lonely and he had no money, the neighbours of my block sympathized with him and they gave him a wake before ? his funeral. It was not the best way they found to join together but it was necessary and they did not doubt that they had to do it. (hesitate about doing it)
However, I believe that my experience is a special one since as the author expresses, today neighborhood ties are not (as) strong as they were some years ago when neighbours shared parties, chats, problems, goods and everything you can imagine (can think of) . Nowadays, all those things have been lost.
People should really value their neighbours since if they need something, their neighbours are the closest to them,and the other way round. If you need sugar...who are the closest to you??Yes!!your neighbour!!! ( I don’t know if you can say the closest. I didn’t find it in the dictionary)

I’ve never imagined that you were so talkative with your neighbours!!! That’s nice.

Probably, you don’t have the same neighbours as I have. I don’t even know many of them jejej :)

Sofía dijo...

I remember that when I was a child(,) I used to spend hours in my neighbours' houses and my parents were friend /friends) of (with) most of them. We always helped each other and got together to celebrate Christmas and new year. It was really great!
Unfortunatelly (unfortunately), some years ago everything changed ( everything changed some years ago). Some people died, others sold their houses, and newcomers moved to the neighbourhood. These new neighbours belong to different provinces and they aren't very greagrious (gregarious) so we don't know them very much. It's a pity because living in a close-knit neghbourhood (neighbourhood)(community)makes you feel more secure and accompanied. Moreover, you know you can count on your neighbours to help you at any time.


What a nice experience Meli!!!! It is true that everything changes, but the most important thing is to keep those great memories in our hearts!

Anónimo dijo...

hey! soy naty.... me olvide mi cuenta.. mando la correccion desde la cuenta de Pao....

Peer correction: Marias' writing

Regrettably, I don’t have many neighbours. In fact, I can’t count more than two; a mad old man (just) across the street and a couple with a baby who are never at home since both of them are doctors…Well, I only run into them once in a blue moon, and when that happens we just look at each other (like saying) / while thinking “I’ve seen you somewhere before” but, that’s all . I wish I had neighbours to chat with, or to exchange a kind “Merry Christmas and happy New Year!” at least once in 365 days. I believe Peter Lovenheim reflects successfully (for me it’s better here) through his story the fact that, although we have access to a developing communication industry, we hardly ever form / establish bonds with those who live next-door; which in the end, is kind of a paradox…isn’t it?

Unknown dijo...

Let me say that I have always had the same neighbours on the right and on the left since I was born! On the right(,) I have a couple of old people who don't have any children(,) and have an excellent(e) relationship with us! We hit it off. But, on the left, (W)we(you should choose I or WE) have (a)very complaining neightbours who(,) last year sent us the police because my dog was barking at 3.00 pm and they could(n)'t sleep(have/take a siesta) the siesta! Of course, we have never said anything about it because(,) as Florencia said, (I)if you need something, the closest to you are your neightbours... (s)So, it is much better to ignore them and keep on living as if (noting had happened) anything wouldn´t happen.

Unknown dijo...

the above is my correction of Juli's work.
( mejor tarde q nunca jeje (: )

gii*

Unknown dijo...

Sofía's comment:

I really like the story for it reflects what HAPPENS in our society nowadays. That is the MAIN reason why I agree with the writer.
It is a fact that people do not usually talk to their neighbours or spend TIME with them speaking about experiences and life. Generally, people do not know anything about THE PERSON who lives next door. It seems that they do not care living this way for they usually consider THOSE who ASK about others’ private lives intolerable GOSSIPERS. What is more, there are some people who do not even say 'hello' to their neighbours when they meet them.
From my point of view, these things happen because we are living in an individualistic society where other persons’ problems or feelings are not taken into account. Besides, as we are split into different groups according to income, race, ideas, etc., it is difficult for us to live as a supportive community where people help each other and share memories and experiences.
Although it is difficult, we should try to cross the social barriers that PREVENT us FROM LIVING as a united and sympathetic neighbourhood.


Meli M.

Unknown dijo...

Peer correction: Meli La´s comment.

I think that the way we relate in my neighbourhood (has) changed mainly because we, neighbours, have grown up, become adults and adapted to the new times. However, I keep very dear memories of them (from) my childhood. There were the ones who told me when to cross the street when I was too (little) to do it on my own, and there were the ones who told me off when I rang their bells and (ran) away. The three best friends I had as a child (were) my three next door neighbours and the whole block was the place to spend the never ending summer afternoons. So, times are changing, yes, but my neighbours´children are still playing on the pavement. Maybe they play with an electronic game instead of a rope, but I (believe) the essence of getting together to have a good time (continues being)in the air. At least, our younger ones have noticed that fact.

Unknown dijo...

Yes, it´s true. We communicate more in Sunchales than in Rafaela. As it is a small city, we know each other and the things each of us does.